Brisket saga Part 1: Meathead Goldwyn on ensuring brisket success

By Joe Heitzeberg - Co-founder and CEO of Crowd Cow. I'm on Instagram at @jheitzeb.

Part 1 of the brisket adventure upon which this writer is embarking.

Fall has arrived with a wet vengeance in Seattle, and with the cooler temperatures comes a hankering for brisket. (Don't you feel it in your bones?)

I've had brisket on the mind for months, because while this writer has prepared many cuts in her day, brisket isn't one of them. So I've set aside an upcoming Saturday that will be fully dedicated to preparing brisket (and which I'm chronicling as part of a bigger project -- more on that soon.)

SHOP: 100% Grass-fed, Grass-finished craft beef

No hormones, no unnecessary antibiotics. Dry-aged beef.

But first, and very importantly, I called up America's Head Honcho of Barbecuing and Grilling and New York Times bestselling author Meathead Goldwyn to steer me right. He shared some vital pointers for ensuring brisket success.

Start with quality meat.

No amount of smoking, poking, or applying fancy spices will turn a bad piece of meat into a good brisket. If you start with high quality beef, you set yourself up for brisket success.

Invest in a digital meat thermometer.

Meathead says “the single most important tool a chef can have is a good thermometer. It's more important than sharp knives." A decent one that reads the temperature in four seconds costs $30.

Trim off most of the fat.

One of the biggest misconceptions Meathead encounters is people thinking "surface fat melts into the surface of the meat.” It doesn't. Plus, if you leave a thick, 1/2-inch layer of fat on the outside, "the first thing everybody's going to do is cut it off, and your spices will go with it." Meathead's method: Trim down to 1/8 inch fat, then spice as you wish.

Up your physics game using the two-zone method.

I told Meathead I'll be cooking my brisket on a gas grill my uncle's lending me for the occasion. "For a gas grill," he advised, “you're going to turn 1 or 2 burners on the far side to medium or high. Leave the others off.” This forms a hot zone and a cooler zone, and the latter is where you want to put your brisket for the gentle cooking powers of "convection air flow." Specifically, you're shooting for 225°F on that cooler side. An oven thermometer is a must for a gas grill.

Cook it low and slow.

Like, for up to 12 hours. Meathead drives this point home, because the number one mistake he sees people make is cooking “too hot and too fast" which causes “the proteins to shrink and squeeze out all the juices," leaving you with tough, dry meat. His advice: "Dial it way back," to 203°F. Here's where that meat thermometer comes in handy.

Stay tuned to hear about how my brisket saga turns out... I'll release Part 2 of this nail-biter later in the fall. Happy barbecuing!

My future brisket

My future brisket. Probably. If all goes well.

SHOP: 100% Grass-fed, Grass-finished craft beef

No hormones, no unnecessary antibiotics. Dry-aged beef.


You may also like

We believe in creating a meaningful connection between you and the food you eat. Taste, transparency and convenience shouldn’t be mutually exclusive. This has been our founding belief since we started in 2015, and it continues to be the force that drives us.
300,000+ happy customers
3000 tons of styrofoam saved with our fully compostable insulation
Over 2 million boxes shipped